Random blog posts about research in political communication, how people learn or don't learn from the media, why it all matters -- plus other stuff that interests me. It's my blog, after all. I can do what I want.
Tuesday, September 13, 2016
Voting
No reason to elaborate. Read this NYTimes piece on who votes, who doesn't, and what predicts the casting of a ballot. It's worth your time.
Friday, September 9, 2016
Georgia Drought Alert
There's an AJC story out about Georgia's drought problem. It's real. To help you see it better, below I provide the drought map roughly one year apart. The older is first, the newer one just below. You can see there's a definite problem in northwest Gerogia, south southeast Georgia seems in better shape. Data from here.
Thursday, September 8, 2016
Georgia Suicides
Much has been written about the increase in suicides among middle age white males -- a topic near and dear to my heart as a middle age white male. See, for example, this Psychology Today article. So I got to wondering, is this happening in Georgia (where I live and teach and, so far, successfully avoid death).
The short answer -- yes.
The longer answer -- there's a trend toward older suicides in Georgia, at least in the data I analyzed.
First the overall trend. Perhaps the best way is to look at the two graphs below, the top one of suicides by age in 1995, the second in 2015. Clearly 2015 skews a bit more toward older folks. As you can see, in 1995 the ages 35-39 and 40-44 had the most suicides. In 2015, the 50-54 age group dominates. If I fit a trend line you'd see in 2015 the data leans more to the right -- that is, older.
OK, but what about white males? The story is similar. Again, see the graphs below. As it shows, there's a bump to the right in the later data, with the 50-54 age category being the most prominent in the 2015 data but the younger categories being more prominent in the 1995 data.
Now some numbers. In 1995 the 50-54 age group of white males made up only 4.5 percent of all suicides. By 2015 that same group was at 7.2 percent of all suicides. Some more numbers. In general, in every year, white males make up most of the suicides. In 2015, for example, it usually hovers around the 60 to 70 percent mark. Simply put, white males tend to make up two-thirds of all suicides in any given year, and sometimes it's as high as nearly nine out of 10. In 2015, there were 1,245 suicides in Georgia, 787 of those being by white males. That's in part because there are more whites than blacks in Georgia, so to really do this I'd need to check it out proportionally, by population, but I'm certain without doing the math it's still higher than you'd expect.
There's more I can do with these data, but it's late in the day.
The short answer -- yes.
The longer answer -- there's a trend toward older suicides in Georgia, at least in the data I analyzed.
First the overall trend. Perhaps the best way is to look at the two graphs below, the top one of suicides by age in 1995, the second in 2015. Clearly 2015 skews a bit more toward older folks. As you can see, in 1995 the ages 35-39 and 40-44 had the most suicides. In 2015, the 50-54 age group dominates. If I fit a trend line you'd see in 2015 the data leans more to the right -- that is, older.
OK, but what about white males? The story is similar. Again, see the graphs below. As it shows, there's a bump to the right in the later data, with the 50-54 age category being the most prominent in the 2015 data but the younger categories being more prominent in the 1995 data.
Now some numbers. In 1995 the 50-54 age group of white males made up only 4.5 percent of all suicides. By 2015 that same group was at 7.2 percent of all suicides. Some more numbers. In general, in every year, white males make up most of the suicides. In 2015, for example, it usually hovers around the 60 to 70 percent mark. Simply put, white males tend to make up two-thirds of all suicides in any given year, and sometimes it's as high as nearly nine out of 10. In 2015, there were 1,245 suicides in Georgia, 787 of those being by white males. That's in part because there are more whites than blacks in Georgia, so to really do this I'd need to check it out proportionally, by population, but I'm certain without doing the math it's still higher than you'd expect.
There's more I can do with these data, but it's late in the day.
Wednesday, September 7, 2016
Car Color and Parking Tickets (at UGA)
In my continuing mission to mine UGA parking ticket data from the last academic year, we turn today to the color of the car and number of tickets written. This is what I do while waiting for my ride home.
The hard part of this analysis is clear. I don't know how many red or black cars there are on campus, plus cars off campus can also get a ticket. In other words, if black cars get the most tickets (they do), that may simply be a function of there being more black cars available on campus -- therefore they get more tickets.
So how do we deal with this problem? We turn to Wikipedia, of course.
This Wikipedia page lists the North America popularity of car colors. It actually has two rankings from two sources, both similar. Below I compare the ranking of North American popularity of car color (using the Dupont Paint list) with the ranking of the number of tickets written on campus last academic year.
As you can see, the lists are remarkably similar. The difference in white and silver is small on the popularity list and very close in tickets written as well. Call it a tie.
You budding methodologists out there see the problem, of course. What's popular in North America isn't necessarily the same pool we're drawing from for cars that happen to park illegally on the University of Georgia campus during the 2015-2016 academic year. Yup, call that a limitation. A caveat. A problem. Other than that, it's kinda interesting that the lists are so similar. And red cars don't make the Top Five at UGA (it's number 6, by the way).
What's it all mean? That I'll do anything to play with data.
The hard part of this analysis is clear. I don't know how many red or black cars there are on campus, plus cars off campus can also get a ticket. In other words, if black cars get the most tickets (they do), that may simply be a function of there being more black cars available on campus -- therefore they get more tickets.
So how do we deal with this problem? We turn to Wikipedia, of course.
This Wikipedia page lists the North America popularity of car colors. It actually has two rankings from two sources, both similar. Below I compare the ranking of North American popularity of car color (using the Dupont Paint list) with the ranking of the number of tickets written on campus last academic year.
|
The
Rank |
American
Popularity |
Tickets on
UGA Campus |
|
1
|
Black
|
Black
|
|
2
|
Silver
|
White
|
|
3
|
White
|
Silver
|
|
4
|
Gray
|
Gray
|
|
5
|
Red
|
Blue
|
As you can see, the lists are remarkably similar. The difference in white and silver is small on the popularity list and very close in tickets written as well. Call it a tie.
You budding methodologists out there see the problem, of course. What's popular in North America isn't necessarily the same pool we're drawing from for cars that happen to park illegally on the University of Georgia campus during the 2015-2016 academic year. Yup, call that a limitation. A caveat. A problem. Other than that, it's kinda interesting that the lists are so similar. And red cars don't make the Top Five at UGA (it's number 6, by the way).
What's it all mean? That I'll do anything to play with data.
Let's Rewrite That Story
I don't often do this, but let's rewrite a student story put online. First off, good job GradyNewsource getting the breaking news online, especially with a pic. It's not a huge story with mostly scrapes from a bus, but that's OK. First off, here's the story. It's about an accident on UGA's east campus. Skim it first and then come back here and let's take a coupla grafs, see if we can improve on them.
The Lede
Later Graf
I'm pressed for time, so let's skip down the story a bit to this sentence:
This story was cranked out fast, so points for getting it online, but take care in how you write it and later go back and clean it up online. No reason to leave it parked there in its original form. Update the thing.
The Lede
Earlier today, around 12:30 p.m., a University of Georgia East Campus Express bus hit a student riding her bike on East Campus Road.Rarely if ever start with the day/time element of a story, and don't use "today" in your story. You don't know when your reader is, ya know, reading the story. Yes, on air it's different, you say "today," but online you put the actual day something happened. Second, do we know the bus hit the student, or vice versa? How about attribution to that point, if you're gonna raise it. Finally, you've put the word East twice in the same sentence. Avoid that by naming the bus route later in the story, if needed, but not in the lede. Instead, write something like: A UGA student suffered minor injuries early Tuesday afternoon when her bike collided with a bus on East Campus. Or something like that. Note how, without attribution, I leave it open as to who is guilty.
Later Graf
I'm pressed for time, so let's skip down the story a bit to this sentence:
There is still no word on if the bus driver has been charged with any crime yet. The name of the student has not been released by authorities.The way this is written you assume the bus driver will be charged with a crime. And I especially hate the word yet in this sentence. Too suggestive. Perhaps she biked in front of the bus, or the bus had the right of way. If you know different, tell me why and who says so, but the sentence above suggests it's the bus drivers fault with no supporting information.
This story was cranked out fast, so points for getting it online, but take care in how you write it and later go back and clean it up online. No reason to leave it parked there in its original form. Update the thing.
Trump is Ford, Clinton is Honda?
So this survey breaks it down by candidate support and make/model of vehicles owned. I got there via this Daily Caller story (yes, I sometimes read it, please don't tell anyone). Essentially, Trump supporters drive American. Clinton supporters drive those other cars and *shudder* Prius. That's the message here, for what little it's worth.
For the record, I drive a Ford.
So what do we know about the methodology? Is this a real poll? It's hard to say. Here's what they report (graphic below), with the yellow circle added by me to point out the details. It's heavy on men by about six percentage points, and we have no idea whether the "all 50 states" were representative of the states or weighted more heavily than they should be of certain, less populous states. All it says in the tiny type below is they "surveyed" folks, nothing about how they did it, whether it was random, or what. They report a margin of error, but that only works if you have a random survey.
f
Thursday, September 1, 2016
Telling People Stuff in a Poll
So there's this PPP poll of Wisconsin, a robo-poll best I can tell. Normally I wouldn't spend much time on it but I found this interesting. Early in the survey they ask respondents about the U.S. Senate race. So:
Check out the wording here:
Let me be clear that private polling for the candidates will often do this kind of thing, sometimes to test approaches in the campaign. Will this issue move voters? This one? How about this one? You don't see it that often in public polling -- which is why I bring it up.
Q1: The candidates for U.S. Senate are Democrat Russ Feingold and Republican Ron Johnson. If the election were today, who would you vote for?Straightforward question, right? Feingold, the Democrat, is up 49-42, with 9 percent undecided. Later in the survey they do something interesting. They ask several questions somewhat critical of Republicans (Questions 3, 4, and 7, for example, see them on the link above).
Check out the wording here:
Q9: During his years in Congress, Ron Johnson has opposed every effort to raise the federal minimum wage. He has repeatedly voted against increasing it, and has even called for getting rid of the federal minimum wage altogether. Does this make you much more likely, somewhat more likely, somewhat less likely or much less likely to support Ron Johnson?OK, that comes kinda close to a push poll, though to be honest that's hard to do in a statewide poll with any effectiveness. And right after this question, there's this:
Q10: Having heard all the information in this poll, let me ask you again: The candidates for U.S. Senate are Democrat Russ Feingold and Republican Ron Johnson. If the election were today, who would you vote for?So all this loaded info, did it affect the poll results? Barely. In Q10, the results still favored Feingold, this time 52-40, with 8 percent undecided. So 1 percent of respondents shifted their position, probably to Feingold, as did a few Johnson supporters. We'd need access to the raw data, or at least more extensive crosstabs, to see if this is truly the case.
Let me be clear that private polling for the candidates will often do this kind of thing, sometimes to test approaches in the campaign. Will this issue move voters? This one? How about this one? You don't see it that often in public polling -- which is why I bring it up.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






