Analyses of national survey data demonstrate that by 16 years of age—but not before— American adolescents manifest levels of development in each quality of citizenship that are approximately the same as those apparent in young American adults who are allowed to vote.As the father of two bright and annoying teens, a 16-year-old and an 18-year-old, I can buy into this. Unfortunately, I can't access the full article and judge the reasoning as well as I'd like, such as comparisons of political sophistication by age. Then again, given the infamous lack of political knowledge found in general among the electorate, my hunch is dropping the age of voting could only improve matters. Or at least not hurt.
Random blog posts about research in political communication, how people learn or don't learn from the media, why it all matters -- plus other stuff that interests me. It's my blog, after all. I can do what I want.
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
Should 16 and 17 year olds vote?
The title above says it all. Should they be able to vote? This piece by Daniel Hart and Robert Atkins argues that these teenagers below 18 are capable of voting. From the abstract:
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Political Efficacy and Journalism
I have of late read a lot about how readers and viewers of the news will either seek out confirming information or, through motivated reasoning, see what they want to see and hear what they want to hear in a news story to fit their political predispositions. The evidence is compelling, especially when you consider how people cling to misperceptions (Obama is a Muslim, etc.), but even corrections by the media of an incorrect fact leads some -- due to partisanship -- to move even further in their misperception. People believe, it seems, what they prefer to believe.
And now along comes this study in the February 2011 Journal of Communication that sorta kinds follows along the same lines.
The study looks at neutral reporting of contradictory factual claims, the basic stuff of everyday journalism, and finds experimentally that exposure to such content influences what they call epistemic political efficacy, defined here as "confidence in one's own ability to determine the truth about factual political disputes." Very interesting concept, one I wish I'd invented, particularly in these times of "death panels" and other invented political factoids. They also consider adjudication, the notion of coming in a news story to some kind of conclusion about the truth or falsity of a disputed fact.
As the article states:
Some interesting ideas here that deserve more time than I can afford to give them, at least at the moment. If I'm lucky I may revisit this study on another day and delve into the whole concept of EPE and how it relates to more traditional approaches to political efficacy. But I do think they're on to something in these hyper-partisan times.
And now along comes this study in the February 2011 Journal of Communication that sorta kinds follows along the same lines.
The study looks at neutral reporting of contradictory factual claims, the basic stuff of everyday journalism, and finds experimentally that exposure to such content influences what they call epistemic political efficacy, defined here as "confidence in one's own ability to determine the truth about factual political disputes." Very interesting concept, one I wish I'd invented, particularly in these times of "death panels" and other invented political factoids. They also consider adjudication, the notion of coming in a news story to some kind of conclusion about the truth or falsity of a disputed fact.
As the article states:
...the two experiments conducted thus far are consistent in finding that at least for readers who are high in prior interest in an issue, encountering even a single news story about that issue that contains adjudication significantly increases their epistemic political efficacy. This suggests that journalistic adjudication may be a point of leverage for increasing the quantity and quality of citizen engagement: goals that may seem unattainable when one assumes that their only important antecedents are motivational constructs such as political interest.
Some interesting ideas here that deserve more time than I can afford to give them, at least at the moment. If I'm lucky I may revisit this study on another day and delve into the whole concept of EPE and how it relates to more traditional approaches to political efficacy. But I do think they're on to something in these hyper-partisan times.
Labels:
journalism,
political efficacy,
political knowledge
Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Egypt -- Not that Interesting?
The Pew folks have an interesting report about the journalistic and public interest. The Egypt mess have you mesmerized? You're more alone than you realized. See below:
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Pepperoni
Okay, in terms of what people know, there are the big questions (political knowledge, do the media inform, why the hell does anyone watch American Idol?) and the small questions. Here, we address one of the smallest of questions in terms of what people know -- or rather, what I know -- about pepperoni.
An article in today's New York Times tells me that favorite of pizza toppings, the ever-popular pepperoni, isn't even Italian.
"Purely an Italian-American creation, like chicken Parmesan," says a food historian.
Ack!
I admit I always thought it was Italian, but apparently the word peperoni is Italian for large peppers, as in bell peppers. Not an Italian salami. I can't help but feel cheated by all those pizza joints, bad Italian eateries, and Hormel, which it seems is the nation's greatest producer of the tasty little red circles.
An article in today's New York Times tells me that favorite of pizza toppings, the ever-popular pepperoni, isn't even Italian.
"Purely an Italian-American creation, like chicken Parmesan," says a food historian.
Ack!
I admit I always thought it was Italian, but apparently the word peperoni is Italian for large peppers, as in bell peppers. Not an Italian salami. I can't help but feel cheated by all those pizza joints, bad Italian eateries, and Hormel, which it seems is the nation's greatest producer of the tasty little red circles.
Monday, January 31, 2011
Good News for the Future?
Yep, my headline above is the beginning of an article title published in the latest Communication Research. And it has a question mark, the up-and-coming trend in academic punctuation.
The full title is:
Good News for the Future?
Young People, Internet Use,
and Political Participation
We can use some good news, right? This survey of 2,409 people, ages 16-24, found that "a variety of Internet uses are positively related with different forms of political participation." That's good news, in particular since it kinda sorta runs counter to both intuition and Bowling Alone suggestions about the Net's impact on people, especially young people. There's also a positive impact for traditional media use, but the authors say it's weak in comparison. Duration of media use isn't what matters, they argue, but rather the type of media used.
In other words, young folks are taking Internet-based media and making it their own -- and such exposure does indeed positively predict participation. That's important for scholars who begin with the assumption that this Net stuff ain't so good.
The full title is:
Good News for the Future?
Young People, Internet Use,
and Political Participation
We can use some good news, right? This survey of 2,409 people, ages 16-24, found that "a variety of Internet uses are positively related with different forms of political participation." That's good news, in particular since it kinda sorta runs counter to both intuition and Bowling Alone suggestions about the Net's impact on people, especially young people. There's also a positive impact for traditional media use, but the authors say it's weak in comparison. Duration of media use isn't what matters, they argue, but rather the type of media used.
In other words, young folks are taking Internet-based media and making it their own -- and such exposure does indeed positively predict participation. That's important for scholars who begin with the assumption that this Net stuff ain't so good.
Thursday, January 27, 2011
Facebook Makes Us Sad
An interesting Slate column discusses recent research on Facebook and its impact on our own attitudes, in particular whether seeing all those shiny happy people makes some folks sadder. It makes sense. Rarely do we post to our newsfeeds the bad stuff, so for some people, seeing this constant feed of happiness, this may result in them reacting negatively.
In general research shows we project more happiness on others than really exists, so the FB thing just feeds it further. The power of projecting such happiness on others, in other words, can influence our own emotional state.
In general research shows we project more happiness on others than really exists, so the FB thing just feeds it further. The power of projecting such happiness on others, in other words, can influence our own emotional state.
Tuesday, January 25, 2011
Driven to Distraction
Sexy News Babes
Drive Male Viewers
to Distraction
Drive Male Viewers
to Distraction
Okay, I wrote the above to grab the attention of those all-important bots that surf the net and end up driving people this direction. But apparently it's true, at least according to this news story about research published in Communication Research (a fine journal because, if for no other reason, I've never appeared in it). An experiment used two primary conditions: one in which a broadcast female news reader wore a tight jacket and skirt that, and I'm not making this up, "accented her waist-to-hip ratio." In the alternate version, the same woman wore "a shapeless and loose-fitting" jacket and skirt. In the previous, lipstick and a necklace, in the latter, neither of them.
According to the story (I've not read the journal article):
The researchers found the men recalled “significantly more information watching the unsexualized anchor deliver news than her sexualized version.” For women, the opposite was true, but the effect was far less pronounced.And yet again, research I wish I had done.
We've all heard about news babes, which demeans hard-working women struggling to make it in journalism, but there's a significant grain of truth to it as well. You don't see a lot of ugly women -- or men -- reading the news. But apparently this gets in the way of learning, which isn't surprising. We've known since research in the 1950s that humor or other factors can get in the way of learning. We can only process so much. There was even the infamous Reagan case in which his PR folks didn't care what the TV reporters said, as long as their visuals got on the screen.
Attractiveness does have positives: it makes a person seem more believable and may even aid in persuasion, or so suggests persuasion models such as the Elaboration Likelihood Model.
So our takeaway? The story says it best: "The study provides evidence for a basic theory of evolutionary psychology: When it comes to processing information, visual tends to trump verbal."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
